Check the year. The figures here are for tax year 2025. Limits and thresholds change, so confirm the current ones before you act.

Two routes can remove a late-filing or late-payment penalty. The first is the IRS's First Time Abate policy. If your record for the previous three years is clean, the IRS will generally agree to waive the penalty for a single return. The second is reasonable cause, which the Code itself provides. It requires you to show that you acted with ordinary business care and still could not file or pay on time.

Both routes cover the penalties for filing late and paying late under section 6651. Neither erases the tax, and neither is guaranteed. If you have a notice in hand, start with what to do when you get an IRS notice, because the response date on it matters more than the abatement question.

What the penalties are, and what is being waived

Section 6651(a)(1) adds 5% of the unpaid tax for each month or part of a month a return is late, up to 25%. Section 6651(a)(2) adds 0.5% of the tax shown on the return for each month or part of a month it goes unpaid, up to 25%. When both apply in the same month, the filing penalty is reduced by the payment penalty for that month, so the combined rate for the first five months is 5% a month, not 5.5%.

A month starts on the due date and runs to the same date of the next month. For an April 15 deadline, the first month ends May 15, and a return filed on June 20 is three months late. If the return is more than 60 days late, a minimum filing penalty applies. For returns due in 2026 the Form 1040 instructions give $525 or the tax owed, whichever is smaller. The payment penalty drops to 0.25% a month during an installment agreement if the return was filed on time, which the balance due options article covers.

These penalties are separate from interest. Interest runs on unpaid tax from the due date even when an extension to file was granted, and it is also charged on the failure-to-file penalty from the return's due date.

First Time Abate: the conditions

First Time Abate lives in the Internal Revenue Manual, not the Code. The Tax Court has said more than once that the Manual does not have the force of law and gives taxpayers no enforceable right, so treat this as an IRS practice that can change. I am describing it the way the court's opinions describe it. Check the current manual text before relying on a detail.

As described there, the policy waives the section 6651(a)(1) and (a)(2) additions the first time a taxpayer is subject to them, which means for a single return. Three conditions come up consistently. You must not have had any unreversed additions to tax in the three years before the year you want relief for. You must have filed, or validly extended, all returns currently due. And you must have paid, or arranged to pay, any tax currently due.

The look-back is about prior penalties, not prior tax bills. A year in which you owed but paid on time does not disqualify you, and neither does a year with a penalty the IRS later reversed. A prior abatement does count against you, so the policy is a one-time reset, not an annual courtesy.

First Time Abate at a glance

Described from Tax Court opinions that cite the Internal Revenue Manual; confirm the current manual before relying on a detail.
QuestionAnswer
Failure-to-file penalty, section 6651(a)(1)Covered
Failure-to-pay penalty, section 6651(a)(2)Covered
Estimated tax penalty, section 6654Not covered; separate narrow waivers in the statute
Clean history requiredNo unreversed section 6651 penalties in the prior three years
Returns requiredAll currently due returns filed or validly extended
Tax requiredPaid, or an arrangement to pay in place
Interest on the taxStill owed

The notice says it that way. Here is what it means.

What you readWhat it means
Failure to file, § 6651(a)(1)The penalty for a late return: 5% a month of the unpaid tax, capped at 25%
Failure to pay, § 6651(a)(2)The penalty for late payment: 0.5% a month, capped at 25%
AbatementRemoval of a penalty
First Time AbateAn IRS practice, not a statute, that waives these penalties for a single return after a clean three years
Unreversed addition to taxA prior penalty that the IRS did not later cancel
Reasonable causeOrdinary business care and prudence, and still unable to file or pay on time

What it does not cover

The estimated tax addition under section 6654 is outside the policy. The Tax Court has held a taxpayer ineligible for the waiver on that penalty because it is not among the penalties the policy lists. The Code gives that penalty its own narrow exceptions: a casualty, disaster or other unusual circumstance, or an underpayment due to reasonable cause by someone who retired after age 62 or became disabled. My safe harbor article covers how to avoid it.

Accuracy-related penalties are a different animal. Section 6664(c) removes them when there was reasonable cause and the taxpayer acted in good faith, which is a legal defense, not a first-time courtesy. A court has said first-time abatement is administrative discretion, not an exception in the Code. Payroll deposit penalties have their own statutory first-time-depositor waiver in section 6656(c), limited to employment taxes, inadvertent failures and the first quarter of required deposits. This article does not cover it further.

Reasonable cause: the standard that is in the law

Both 6651 penalties yield if the failure was due to reasonable cause and not willful neglect. The regulation defines it. For filing, you exercised ordinary business care and prudence and were nevertheless unable to file on time. For payment, you made a satisfactory showing that you exercised ordinary business care and prudence in providing for payment, and were either unable to pay or would suffer undue hardship by paying on the due date.

The payment standard looks at your finances before the due date. The regulation says a taxpayer who runs up lavish or extravagant living expenses, so that the remaining assets and income cannot cover the tax, has not shown ordinary business care. Investing in speculative or illiquid assets fails the same test unless enough remained to pay the tax.

On the filing side, delegation does not help. The Tax Court, following the Supreme Court's decision in Boyle, holds that relying on an agent to file is not reasonable cause for a late return. A preparer's mistake about the deadline is not a defense. Facts that do count include a serious illness, a disaster or an inability to obtain records, though each is judged on its own record.

One built-in protection applies to extensions. If you timely extended an individual return, reasonable cause is presumed for the extension period when the tax paid by the original due date came within 10% of the tax shown and you pay any balance with the return. See what still has to happen after an extension.

Worked example

Example, hypothetical: what the penalties cost

A single filer has $12,000 of unpaid tax for 2025 after withholding. The return was due April 15, 2026. They file and pay everything on June 20, 2026, which is 66 days late and three months by the statute's counting. Assume no extension, no installment agreement and no reasonable-cause claim.

The filing penalty is 5% a month for three months, or 15% of $12,000, which is $1,800. The payment penalty is 0.5% for three months, or 1.5%, which is $180. Because both applied in each of those months, the filing penalty is cut by $180 to $1,620. The total is $1,800 before interest. The $525 minimum does not matter here because the computed penalty is higher. If the policy's conditions were met, the abatement request would target the whole $1,800.

Total penalties by months late, $12,000 of tax filed and paid together
$0$1k$2k$3k$4kFailure to file (net) plus failure to pay: $600$6001 monthFailure to file (net) plus failure to pay: $1,200$1.2k2 monthsFailure to file (net) plus failure to pay: $1,800$1.8k3 monthsFailure to file (net) plus failure to pay: $2,400$2.4k4 monthsFailure to file (net) plus failure to pay: $3,000$3k5 monthsFailure to file (net) plus failure to pay: $3,060$3.1k6 monthsFailure to file (net) plus failure to pay: $3,180$3.2k8 monthsFailure to file (net) plus failure to pay: $3,420$3.4k12 months
Total penalties by months late, $12,000 of tax filed and paid together
Failure to file (net) plus failure to pay
1 month$600
2 months$1,200
3 months$1,800
4 months$2,400
5 months$3,000
6 months$3,060
8 months$3,180
12 months$3,420

Penalties climb 5% a month through month five, then slow to 0.5% a month once the filing penalty hits its 25% cap.

Computed from 26 U.S.C. 6651(a)(1), (a)(2) and (c)(1), hypothetical $12,000 of tax, no interest, no reasonable cause

Same return, filed on time but paid September 20, 2026
$360Failure-to-pay penalty, 6 months at 0.5%
$0Failure-to-file penalty

Paying late on a timely return costs far less than filing late, which is one reason to file even when you cannot pay.

How to ask

The regulation's stated form for a reasonable-cause showing is a written statement, signed under penalties of perjury, setting out all the facts. The Form 1040 instructions say that if you have a reasonable explanation for filing late, you include it with the return. For a penalty notice on an employment tax account, Publication 15 likewise says you can send an explanation of why reasonable cause exists. I found no rule fixing the form for a First Time Abate request, so follow the instructions on your notice and ask about the policy by name.

If you have already paid the penalty, a request for a refund of it goes on Form 843, Claim for Refund and Request for Abatement, not on an amended return. The Tax Court has dealt with Forms 843 that were unsigned and could not be processed, and has said blanket statements without proof do not support abatement. Give dates, what you did, and documents.

Common mistakes

  • Asking for first-time relief while another return is unfiled or a balance is neither paid nor on a payment plan.
  • Assuming First Time Abate is still available after a prior abatement, when a prior abatement within the three-year window counts against you.
  • Expecting the policy to cover the section 6654 estimated tax penalty or accuracy-related penalties.
  • Claiming reasonable cause because a preparer or software missed the deadline.
  • Sending a request with no dates, no documents and no signature.
  • Waiting for the penalty to be removed before paying the tax, which leaves the payment penalty growing and interest running.

The usual way versus doing it right

The usual

Ask and hope

  1. Request relief while another return is unfiled or the tax is unpaid
  2. Blame the preparer or software for the missed deadline
  3. Send a request with no dates, documents or signature
Done right

Qualify, then document

  1. File every return due and pay or arrange to pay first
  2. Check the three-year history, then pick First Time Abate or reasonable cause
  3. Send a signed written request with dates and documents

What to do

  1. Read the notice

    Note the response date, the tax periods and which penalty is named. Do not let a deadline pass while you plan an abatement request.

  2. Check the compliance conditions

    File every return currently due and pay the tax or set up a payment plan. Without that, First Time Abate is not available.

  3. Look back three years

    Pull your IRS account transcripts for the three years before the penalty year and see whether any 6651 penalties were assessed and not reversed.

  4. Choose the ground

    If the three-year history is clean, ask for First Time Abate by name. If not, build a reasonable-cause statement with dates and documents.

  5. Put the request in writing

    Describe what happened, when, and what you did, sign it under penalties of perjury and keep a copy. Use Form 843 if the penalty has been paid.

  6. Plan the next deadline

    A penalty waived once will not be waived on the same terms again, so calendar the next filing and payment dates.

If you want help deciding which route fits and drafting the request, that is part of tax return preparation. For a CP2000 or other notice with a penalty attached, see how to answer a CP2000 notice.